Sign Up
..... Connect Australia with the world.
Categories

Posted: 2022-06-03 20:02:54

As a 24-year-old person of short stature, for most of my life I've been subjected to a body measurement system designed for people of average height – the body mass index (BMI).

My first recollection of getting my BMI measured was in year seven.

I hated sport because I wasn't as fast as everyone else, so I played Wii Fit for 30 minutes every day for the first few years of high school to stay fit.

Its BMI test classified me as being overweight, and my Mii avatar reflected this. I pictured that must be how I looked in real life, and I felt ashamed.

BMI can be a good guide to help estimate if someone falls within a healthy weight range, but it's not a one-size-fits-all measure.

Julie Dickson prepares to do a stand and jump.
The body mass index uses a weight-to-height ratio to determine if someone is within a healthy weight range.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

"It uses a weight-to-height ratio that's been standardised to the 'normal' population group," said Tracy Tate, a senior physiotherapist who specialises in working with people of short stature.

So why, as a person who doesn't fit that 'normal' mould, am I being held to a standard I was never supposed to meet?

I know I'm not alone when I say it's had a negative effect on both my physical and mental health.

Julie Dickson poses for a photo in front of a wall with tulip pictures on it.
Julie's physical and mental health went on a downward spiral after being told she was overweight.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

Getting the wrong impression

The false perception of being overweight can leave a lasting impact.

She stresses using BMI data in an inappropriate context can have negative effects.

Kobie, Merry, and Sammy are all people of short stature who've experienced the same feelings as I have in this space.

A short statured woman out for a run on in suburbia.
Kobie had her BMI taken and said it made her second guess her diet and exercise regime.(Supplied)

We met and became friends through Short Statured People of Australia (SSPA) – an organisation that connects and provides support to people of short stature.

They, too, have struggled with body image their whole lives.

Twenty-eight-year-old Kobie is a health and physical education teacher, and she says getting her BMI taken made her feel uncomfortable.

Forty-three-year-old Merry is a senior education officer and was also told she was overweight.

A short statured woman bounces a basketball in an Australia uniform.
Merry's BMI signified she was overweight, despite the fact she was actively playing a wide variety of competitive sports.(Supplied: Alan Holben Photography)

Thirty-three-year-old Sammy, who is a senior advisor in diversity and inclusion, reflects on having a similar experience.

Sammy, a short stature woman, leans on the side of a swimming pool and smiles.
Sammy feels like she's been walking a tightrope her whole life, when it comes to exercise, weight and diet.(Supplied)

As a gym-goer, I recently participated in a challenge in which my BMI was measured – again, it classified me as overweight.

So I exercised too much and ate less. I was undernourished and constantly thinking about food, so I couldn't concentrate properly when studying or reading and writing for pleasure.

But then I opened up to the staff about the impact that number was having on me, and they understood. I didn't see my BMI again during that challenge.

For me, the unhealthy habits of overexercising and eating less have been hard to break. I know it's not the answer, but it's something I still struggle with.

Julie Dickson looks ahead as she lifts a bar with 15 kilogram weights on either end.
Julie goes to the gym on a regular basis, but still struggles with determining what's healthy for her.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

So what can we do to promote body diversity?

My gym has a supportive community and is a safe environment to challenge myself, which makes me feel strong both physically and mentally. 

Awareness is essential, as friends, family and people we cross paths with will often play a role in shaping and influencing our perception of ourselves.

I feel if the people close to me had been more aware of the potential negative effect of BMI measuring and its impracticality, the support would have been invaluable.

Julie Dickson, a short statured woman, sits on a bench at a gym.
Julie feels comfortable at her gym, but had to explain her situation so that her BMI wouldn't be taken anymore.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

Liana Tieri is an accredited practising dietitian and says there are many ways to promote body diversity. Here are some of them:

  • Celebrate, embrace, and accept all shapes and sizes
  • Avoid judging a person's health, or eating and exercise behaviours, based on their weight, shape, or appearance, as a healthy body can present in a range of shapes or sizes
  • Avoid using language that increases feelings of guilt or shame around eating or weight, such as bad, junk, or toxic
  • Educate yourself about diet culture
  • Be mindful of, and reduce toxic and unhelpful diet, body, and appearance talk and find other things to discuss
Julie Dickson smiles as she sits on a gym bench and holds a weight in each hand.
Julie wants to raise awareness around the issue of BMI not being right for people of short stature.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

Inclusivity is also really important

Our focus needs to shift away from using the BMI measuring system as a one-size-fits-all approach, and more towards moving and nourishing our bodies in a way that makes us feel good.

Without using the BMI, people of short stature can still have fitness and health goals.

My gym is quite inclusive, when there's equipment out of reach, the staff adjust it before I get to it, but it's not the same everywhere.

Fitskills is an initiative that's looking to do just that.

Julie Dickson, a short statured woman, planks on two weights.
It's hoped a new program aimed at getting more people with a disability in the gym will improve their quality of life.(ABC Sport/Siren Sport: Megan Brewer)

Opening up opportunities

Led by Professor Nora Shields from La Trobe University, FitSkills provides young people who have a disability with support and assistance so they can feel confident exercising at their local gym and improve their quality of life.

Loading

The program matches a young person with a disability with a local mentor, and together, they exercise at their local gym twice a week for 12 weeks.

"That's not because they don't exist, we just need to have a different perspective, we need to come at the issue from a different angle."

The aim of the study is to demonstrate how gyms can be more inclusive of people with a disability and to move this small-scale university-led initiative into the wider community.

A program that could open a whole new world to some.

As for me, I'm moving forward and trying to put letters and numbers aside.

I'm taking ownership of my body back, because why should it be defined by a number it was never supposed to meet?

Julie Dickson is a freelance writer based in Melbourne. She is studying a Bachelor of Psychology (Honours) at Deakin University and is currently an intern with ABC Sport.

View More
  • 0 Comment(s)
Captcha Challenge
Reload Image
Type in the verification code above