The AAT has returned to the department of prime minister and cabinet’s case after hearing Rex Patrick’s submissions about the status of national cabinet this morning.
Justice White has started the afternoon session with a challenge to the department: where in the evidence is there proof that it was a decision of the prime minister to set up the national cabinet?
Counsel for the department, Andrew Berger, said:
It was established by agreement of the prime minister, premiers and chief ministers. Although it was a collective decision to establish it, the power or authority stemmed from the prime minister. If the PM hadn’t have agreed, it couldn’t have been established.
Berger said it is “beside the point” whether Scott Morrison set it up individually or collectively in consultation with others.
Earlier, justice White asked whether the affidavit of Phil Gaetjens, the departmental secretary, states whether he was present at the Council of Australian Governments meeting setting up national cabinet.
The answer was: no, it doesn’t say.